You think it would be logical to make a Voyager movie, because it well… quite simply rocked!

I was very mad that they never created a voyager movie… I would love to see one.. even now.

Wonderful acting and directing, thank you Tim Russ.

1) FAR BEYOND THE STARS
2) THE VISITOR
3) WHAT YOU LEAVE BEHIND
4) HOMEFRONT/PARADISE LOST 2-PARTER
(ESPECIALLY RELEVANT POST 9/11)
5) TRIALS & TRIBBLE-ATIONS
6) RAPTURE
7) FACETS
8) IN THE HANDS OF THE PROPHETS
9) THE HOMECOMING/THE CIRCLE/THE SIEGE TRILOGY
10) DRAMATIS PERSONAE

TOP 10 VOYAGER ( NO PARTICULAR ORDER)

1) TIMELESS
2) (TIE) LIVING WITNESS & TUVIX
3) ENDGAME
4) YEAR OF HELL
5) THE ‘37′S
6) EQUINOX 1 & 2
7) COURSE: OBLIVION
8) PARALLAX
9) SCORPION 1 & 2
10) UNIMARTIX ZERO 1 & 2

OGAM wasn’t bad. I’ll definitely watch the other two parts. The acting is certainly better than New Voyages. I didn’t realize they were using Cawley’s sets. I would’ve preferred the newer style, but I guess we’re talking budgets here. I’m sure it’s a real hoot for the nostalgic among us, but I grew up with TOS and I’ve seen enough of that old, improbable-looking bridge. It’s so cheap and fake looking. Get rid of it. It had its time. That was in the 60s, when painted plywood and blinking lights were enough. Thank God JJ Abrams has updated it.

Finally. A voice of reason.

I actually liked the episodes with the Vidians, but they abandoned them pretty quickly. And I thought Endgame was pretty pointless. It was a very similar plot (as some have already pointed out) to Timeless & Year of Hell (both of which I felt were done better), and it featured the Borg, a race that Voyager managed to ruin on an almost weekly basis in Seasons 5-7. I think the Borg are the kind of villain the audience THINKS it wants to see more often, but that are best used sparingly. Even TNG crossed that line. I,Borg was interesting, but when they revisted the concept in Descent, it all turned to crap.

Yes Season 2 definitely did have a lot stinkers, although it did have some bright spots. I always liked the season ender “Basics: Part 1″ with the Kazon trap and their takeover of Voyager. But for some reason Part 2 didn’t do it for me. Seemed that the re-taking of the ship was a little too easy.

I also liked “Projections,” “Alliances,” “Meld” & “Lifesigns” for Season 2 in addition to the previously mentioned “Death Wish” & “Deadlock.”

For some reason that I can’t really explain, Voyager has always held a special place in my fanboy heart despite its flaws. I got into it more than DS9 or Enterprise. It appears I’m in the minority though according to the postings I read here. Gotta go with TNG as my fave though.

As for DS9, Season 1 was shaky but had some gems like Emissary, the best opener of all the series. Also the characters were pretty spot on from the start. Season 2 was fun, Season 3 really ramped it up, Season 4 was DS9 on speed… this is where the show kicked into overdrive. Seasons 5, 6 & 7 built on the strength of Season 4.

I loved TNG growing up a kid, I was simply spellbound by it. Nothing compared to it, but DS9 was Trek at its best.

As for Enterprise… should never have been made. Trek should have been laid to rest for a few years.

Rant over :)

Was that Montgomery in ST:III who called Sulu “tiny”? It looks like him from a picture of you both (in the ST:TMP in the crowd where Kirk yells “screen off – SCREEN OFF!.” I haven’t got the credits in front of me.

What does Tim play? Electric? Accoustic? What would you say his style is?

What did you play in the band (or did you sing)? Did your father play any instruments?

I was so sorry to see your father go. He was a class act. I didn’t know him but he seemed like a wonderful man. Hope you and your family are well. Is your mother still with us?

kg

Steve Adam – I also respect your opinion. I wouldn’t mind seeing you top ten.