Book Review: John Scalzi’s ‘Redshirts’ | TrekMovie.com
jump to navigation

Book Review: John Scalzi’s ‘Redshirts’ June 14, 2012

by Robert Lyons , Filed under: Books,Great Links,Review , trackback

The secrets of the Universal Union’s flagship are exposed as newbie crew members continue to die exquisitely meaningless deaths in John Scalzi’s new sci-fi sendup, “Redshirts”. It isn’t an official Star Trek novel, but the title gives it away as a Trek spoof. The TrekMovie review follows…

 

REVIEW: Redshirts – A novel in three codas
by John Scalzi
Hardcover – 320 pages
Tor Books – June 2011 – $16.49 (Amazon)

As far as things go in the Universal Union, it doesn’t get much more prestigious than the Intrepid, fleet flagship, and home of Captain Abernathy, Science Officer Q’eeng, and a whole host of other spectacular and not-so-spectacular spacers. Enter Ensign Andrew Dahl, fresh off a stint in a monastery on the planet Forsham, where an ongoing religious brouhaha has ensured that his safety is less than minimal. After some time at the Union’s Academy, he is posted to the Intrepid, where he quickly discovers that little is quite what it appears.

Aboard the Intrepid, nonsense seems to be the normal routine. Gibberish passes for science, the same decks keep getting blown out, a wild yeti roams the bowels of the ship, and new crew members routinely die in the most improbable of ways.

Welcome to the world created by John Scalzi in his new novel, “Redshirts”.

As the story unfolds, Andy Dahl befriends several Intrepid crew members who quickly discover that everyone on the ship is aware of a very real trend among new recruits – they don’t tend to survive very long. No, not survive in the sense of make it on the Intrepid… survive in the sense of live and breathe.

Of course, ‘middle management’ has already figured out a solution, compliments of a certain biological entity aboard who has already managed to figure out the system, a way to game it, and the insanity behind it.

Now he just needs to send Andy Dahl and his friends on a bit of a trip, and what could possibly be a better excuse than to have Dahl sent on a mission back to Forshan where he would, of course, be facing a particularly gruesome death.

To be honest, having never read Scalzi, I had no real idea what to expect in terms of writing style and perspective. As president of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America and a New York Times bestselling author, Scalzi’s name brings a certain expectation with it to reading (even if only by way of these distinctions). I am not quite sure that I would say that “Redshirts” disappointed… but I am sure that I can say that it’s not what I expected.

For one, the story doesn’t remain confined to a far-flung future, but finds a firm connection to the here and now, namely in the minds of three Orange County, California residents – Nick Weinstein, Matthew Paulson, and Samantha Martinez. The trio, living lives that have only the remotest of connections, influence (or are influenced by – the narrative leaves that an open-ended exploration) events and lives for Dahl and his friends.

The bulk of Dahl’s story, and the Intrepid’s narrative, is cardboard dull. Scalzi wastes no time on developing a setting for the story, leaving only the barest of hints from which to extrapolate a setting. I don’t think this is a problem with the one-off book format, however, as I have read plenty of one-off books and short stories whose environments are brought vividly to life. "Childhood’s End" and "Imperial Earth" (Arthur C. Clarke) come quickly to mind as two examples. As I read, my mind rebelled against using established Star Trek visuals to populate the setting. While the story is obviously a tongue-in-cheek take on the space opera, it doesn’t give any credible clues towards looking Trek-like. It leaves one with the impression of a poorly-designed stage play or, worse, a stage play with no sets at all. This largely pushes the focus onto the characters, which is good, but it does so at the expense of emphasizing the reality of the mission of the Intrepid, which doesn’t serve the overall story well.

The OC trio’s story, by contrast, is far easier to visualize, and thus has a far deeper potential hook to compel the reader. Mentions of P.F. Chang’s, TMZ, and a Verizon store seem somewhat out of place in most space-operas, but, then again, “Redshirts” isn’t ultimately about the space-opera… is it?

Concluding the main narrative, I was left feeling very flat. Given what I had read about Scalzi’s work, and given the advance praise for the book, I frankly felt cheated. “Redshirts” is funny, but – with all due respect to Joe Hill, not ‘ruin-your-underwear funny’; and I fail to see how it reassembles the Star Trek universe in a more plausible fashion. If that’s what you are looking for, which is what I expected going into the book, then “Redshirts” is an utter disappointment. (Perhaps the Wil Wheaton read audio version would enhance the humor?) But I don’t think that’s what “Redshirts” is really about… or what ultimately makes the story worth reading.

“Redshirts” is, I think, about the interconnectedness of all things. If you let it, the book explores some pretty deep questions about the way we relate to the universe around us, which gives the story a chance to really engage the reader. For me it was not the bulk of the story, but the three codas which follow the main body which carried the most weight, and the most enjoyment… three codas which really speak to the way the universe at large can alter our paths, even today.

To be clear, there is no room for a “Redshirts II”… “Redshirts” brings itself to a satisfying enough conclusion. Just remember, as you read, that someplace, someone, somewhere in the timeline is wearing a red shirt… and their horrible death by ice shark can shake the fabric of the universe, all the way to the Bangs.

"Redshirts" is available now in Hardcover, Kindle and Audible Audiobook (read by Wil Wheaton).  You can read an excerpt at Tor.com.

 

Tor Books provided TrekMovie with a review copy for this article.

Comments

1. Commodore Mike of the Terran Empire - June 14, 2012

I am not sure about this one. But. We will see. Just don’t wear a Red Shirt.

2. grover s - June 14, 2012

I’m surprised this Redshirt-themed item hasn’t gotten more attention:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=geylF6OJsSw

3. MJ - June 14, 2012

I wish I had thought of this!

4. averybrooksforprez - June 14, 2012

Thanks for the review!

I’ve found Scalzi’s writing to be patchy. Old Man’s War was incredible, one of my favorite sci-fi reads ever. But the follow up, Ghost Brigade, was so painfully tedious I couldn’t finish it.

Red Shirts sounds interesting, perhaps I’ll check out the free sample first and see how the writing is.

5. NuFan - June 14, 2012

I liked the book. The story was out of the ordinary in a Galaxy Quest kinda way. Anyone expecting a serious science fiction or Trek related story is gonna be disappointed. And his wit/humor is a specific cup of tea; not everyone will like it.

I dont think he intended it to be anything but a fun little throwaway story.

6. psb2009 - June 14, 2012

I liked it, thought it was fun. Not Shakespeare, but I thought there were some good thoughts about the value of a life well-lived and a little story about love transcending time and space (and fiction).

7. saavik001 - June 14, 2012

I thought it was good, not his best but a good one. Agent to the Stars i thought was funnier.

8. fansincesixtynine - June 14, 2012

It is not his best work, that is for sure.

9. Tiberius Subprime - June 14, 2012

John Scalzi is a writer riding on the success of “Old Man’s War”. In my opinion, this was his only really good novel. The rest have been very flat and boring. Nad, in my opinion, badly written.

I find it odd how they (publisher, his critic-friends in the industry, the SFWA) keep praising the guy when many readers are finding him a one-trick pony. (With Scalzi, the old saying seems true: everyone has at least one novel in them.)

I only bought his other novels based on the success of “Old Man’s War”, as I suspect other readers did. I am weary of buying any more books from him.

I suspect this send-up novel was an attempt to go in a whole new direction and re-invigorate his sales, which have dropped off recently.

10. CmdrR - June 15, 2012

Parodies are hot stuff these days.
Wonder if Anthony’s gonna sell a collection of our stuff from chat.
BND’s alone ought to be worth a pretty penny. That’s about how much a publisher will pay unless you throw in an interpreter.
(keeeeeeeeeeding!)

11. NuFan - June 15, 2012

5

That name is taken.

12. Curious Cadet - June 15, 2012

@2 that’s cute, but Redshirt Blues is the all time classic red shirt parody …

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVduvWTxQ5w

13. Marcelo - June 15, 2012

I really liked it. I think if real people were in Starfleet they’d behave like these characters, not like Trek characters – they’d deal a few space drugs on the side, be science-positive and incredulous and skeptical (the scene where they introduce The Box is priceless), and sleep with senior officers just because they’re bored. They’d avoid work if their boss wasn’t looking.

I thought the conclusion was pretty fun too, albeit unsatisfying. It never went as meta as I thought it would, nor did it parody some of the next level Trek tropes as much as I hoped it would. But it was ultimately satisfying, then forgettable. A single day read. Which is nice in the summertime.

14. grover s - June 15, 2012

@12
Definitely, that one is great too, which is probably why it didn’t stay under the radar so much, with ~34000 views. The video I linked to was very creative and entertaining, with a really different and humorously dark take on the Redshirt phenom, but only had a few hundred views after a year.

15. OlderFan - June 15, 2012

11 Apologies… I go by OlderFan and musta had a brain fart when I typed the name (maybe you were in my head or I was thinking of NuTrek.

TrekMovie.com is represented by Gorilla Nation. Please contact Gorilla Nation for ad rates, packages and general advertising information.