Star Trek:The Next Generation Season 4 Blu-ray review | TrekMovie.com
jump to navigation

Star Trek:The Next Generation Season 4 Blu-ray review August 1, 2013

by Matt Wright , Filed under: DVD/Blu-ray,Review,TNG Remastered , trackback

Season 4 is the start of the well oiled machine that we knew as TNG, coming off the success of Season 3 and the attention of using the cliffhanger format for “The Best of Both Worlds”, Season 4 is the first season to have all of the production staff that would be there through the series end. Season 4 contains a lot of fan favorites such as Family, Brothers, Data’s Day, The Wounded, The Drumhead, Qpid, and Redemption. Read on to see how the season looks remastered and details of the new bonus features.

The Episodes

Season 4 gives us a lot of episodes that help to expand the characters we had come to know and like by the end Season 3. It’s also the first season that the writers slip in follow ups to previous episodes. One of the most obvious being the immediate follow-up to “Best of Both Worlds II”, the episode “Family”, where Picard returns home. We get to see Picard start to heal some of his emotional wounds from the Borg and deal with others he’s harbored a long time towards his older brother.

family_02_small

Another major driving force to Season 4 is Worf’s character development, that started back in Season 2 with “The Emissary” (one could even argue it goes as far back as Season 1′s “Heart of Glory”), continued in Season 3′s “Sins of the Father”, and now Season 4 gives us more bits and pieces of Worf’s human and Klingon back story in “Family”, “Reunion”, and of course “Redemption.” Geordi gets his infatuation with Dr. Leah Brahms followed up, with the real women this time, in “Galaxy’s Child”, which features what is only the second major use of CGI in TNG, and one of the most prominent, the space baby, called “Junior” by the Enterprise crew. Vash comes back into Picard’s life, as does Q, in the rather silly but fun “Qpid.”

qpid_03_small

Brent Spiner gets to show his acting chops in three Data centric episodes, “Brothers” (where he does triple duty!), “Data’s Day”, and “In Theory”, where Data attempts a relationship simulation.

brothers_01_small

Gates McFadden gets a rare chance to take center stage in “Remember Me.” Barclay’s social anxiety and intelligence seemingly make him the perfect vessel for an alien program in “The Nth Degree.”

nth_03_small

We get another powerful courtroom drama in the form of “The Drumhead.” Even O’Brien, who had mostly just stood in the transporter room, gets married in “Data’s Day”, and has his backstory fleshed out in the “The Wounded”.

datasday_01_small

Riker gets out from under his second-in-command position in “the future” of “Future Imperfect”, and has to pull a James Bond and sleep with his alien nurse to try to get free in “First Contact.” Picard battles a she-devil in the courtroom in ”Devil’s Due.” Geordi gets brainwashed by Romulans in “Mind’s Eye” in an homage to The Manchurian Candidate (also laying the foundation for Romulan involvement in “Redemption”), poor Geordi also nearly becomes a cowering glow-in-the-dark alien in “Identity Crisis.” Data may be lying to the crew for reasons unknown in “Clues.” Troi loses her powers in “The Loss”, and can only have nightmares in “Night Terrors.” Oh and Tasha Yar’s sister, who stayed behind at the hell hole of a colony they grew up on, plays the Enterprise crew for fools in “Legacy”, lastly Wesley finally heads off to the academy after missing his chance last year, but first he goes on a “Final Mission” with Captain Picard and gets a little psudo-father-son-time. Phew!

Video and Audio Quality

The audio is once again generally excellent DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 mixes.

CBS Home Entertainment wanted three seasons released in 2013, to facilitate that timetable, Season 4 was partly outsourced to a third-party production house. After the rather mediocre Season 2 release, which was done entirely by a 3rd party company, CBS Digital took a different approach, as well as used a different company this time. CBS Digital handled the live-action elements and the final “conform” of the episodes (i.e. they edited the episodes back together to match the original sequences), only the visual effects were handled by another company called Modern Video. Unlike Season 2, this time CBS Digital said they were keeping a close eye on the work Modern Video did, and they said they shared their existing art assets with them.

So the good news is that the live action portions look consistent with Season 3, and the visual effects look very good, they’re at maybe 90% of what CBS Digital does when they do the VFX in-house. CBS Digital just seems to put some extra care and love into their work. However, as you’ll see from the images in this article, the vast majority of the time things look great, and you’d be hard pressed to know someone else did the VFX work, especially without some kind of side-by-side comparison.host_01_small

There is one rather poor scene, and it’s entirely CGI, the birth scene of the space baby in “Galaxy’s Child” has a very hard edged ”computer graphicy” look, somewhat more-so than the original ’90s version, it’s a shame a little more time wasn’t spent on getting the lighting and texturing just right, but I suppose it’s not a huge deal in the grand scheme of things. The rest of the episode is faithfully recreated.

gc_01_small Recreated
gc_01_sd_orig_small
Original

Bonus Material

The bonus features have been what’s really made the past season releases. Perhaps owing to the aforementioned Season 4 being where the show hit its stride, the documentaries this time aren’t quite as engaging, but generally still a good watch.

Audio commentaries – “Brothers” with the director Rob Bowman and Mike & Denise Okuda and “Reunion” with Ron D. Moore, Brannon Braga and Mike & Denise Okuda.

All of the new video features are on Disc 6 of the set:

Documentaries

As Season 4 had become a well oiled machine, people involved in all aspects of the production really started to feel a sense of family with their co-workers, so fittingly, this is theme of the documentaries on the set.

As with previous season sets, there is a multipart documentary that discusses the season, this season it is called: “Relativity: The Family Saga of Star Trek: The Next Generation“, each part is 30 minutes:

Part 1 – “Homecoming” – Focuses on production/writing, the open script submission policy, how much the writing side of the production staff was like a big family that fought and made up and generally just loved collaborating. Trek author Larry Nemecek basically provides context to the background of the season with comments similar to those that he wrote in his TNG Companion book. Ron D. Moore, Branon Braga, Rene Echevarria, and Lolita Fatjo all have great things to say about the writing staff and the open script submission policy, and of course, their leader, the late Michael Pillar.

Part 2 – “Prosperity” – This section focuses on the episodes, and the actors getting to really play their characters, getting good character moments, etc. Brent Spiner is featured heavily since he gets a lot of work in Season 4 (“Brothers”, “Data’s Day”, and “In Theory”). Director Rob Bowman discusses the technicalities of shooting Spiner as three different people in “Brothers.” Michael Dorn discusses Worf and how he was used as a comedic “straight man” (cut to a shot of Worf saying he is not a merry man), Wil Wheaton discusses leaving, plus Patrick Stewart, Jonathan Frakes, Marina Sirtis, and Gates McFadden chime on their episodes and the season in general. Surprisingly, outside of Wil Wheaton’s own self-conscious reflection, nothing else is said about his leaving the show.

A second documentary is included, this is a conversational piece, filmed in Doug Drexler’s living room.

In Conversation: The Star Trek Art Department” (67 minutes) – This sit-down includes Herman Zimmerman, Rick Sternbach, Mike and Denise Okuda, Doug Drexler and visual effects supervisor Dan Curry. Doug leads off with a little bit of an introduction in the boysterious way that he has. Doug has major praise for Herman Zimmerman. The group points out that if Zimmerman hadn’t hired Mike Okuda, Mike would have never met his wife Denise (who of course also eneded up working on Trek). Those present all echo the idea of family (the theme of the documentaries on this season set), and how great it was to work with all the people in the art and visual effects departments. This chat you might find a bit boring if you don’t already know a bit about the production side of things. If you’re interested in those aspects there are some good annecdotes and nuggets of information throughout the conversation. Zimmerman is a wealth of information about the creation of the sets for TNG and the early days of pre-production, including anecdotes on the humor of Bob Justman’s memo writing. The conversation goes to the creation of the space station on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and how it was one of the best collaborations between everyone in the art departments.

Gag Reel – Like season 3, this is a brand new gag reel made from the 35mm negatives found in the archives. It’s short at 3:34 minutes and unfortunately not nearly as good as the previous seasons.

Deleted Scenes – This Season we get a treasure trove of deleted scenes! This is probably the best bonus material on the set. These aren’t blurry VHS workprint versions, the Blu-ray production team found the original 35mm scenes and scanned them in at 1080p.

Best of Both Worlds II – Riker voices his doubts and confesses that Picard was more of a father to him than his own to Troi in the ready room. This scene was best left on the cutting room floor. It’s quite melodramatic and is rendered superfluous by the much better “tough love” scene with Guinian and Riker in the ready room that is in the final version.

Family – Wesley’s father describes his family history (for example: there was a Crusher who was a horse thief on Nimbus III, a reference to Star Trek V)

Brothers - Cut dialog from when Data first meets Dr. Soong, Soong tests Data’s reflexes and discusses what a humid day feels like, and more.

Final Mission – 1.) A nice moment in the cave between Wesley and the injured Picard, where Picard says he can see Jack Crusher in Wesley’s face.
2.) A short scene set on the bridge as they enter orbit of the moon Lambda Paz and find that due to interference they need to send a shuttle down instead of using the transporter.

The Wounded – By far some of the best and largest number of cut scenes are from The Wounded.
1.) A little lecture about treating the Cardassians as guests is cut from the bridge discussion on guarding the Cardassian visitors
2.) A scene with O’Brien and Riker in the transporter room, with O’Brien defending Captain Maxwell.
3.) More from the dinner with O’Brien and Keiko where she asks him how he feels about the Cardassians
4.) Chasing Maxwell from the Enterprise, on the bridge there is a bit more discussion of the implications of what relaying the prefix codes to the Cardassian warship would mean.
5.) As Maxwell is escorted to the bridge to see Picard, Maxwell calls the Enterprise a “sweet ship” and reacts badly to the Cardassian commander being on the bridge.
6.) In the ready room scene with Maxwell and Picard, Maxwell admits he doesn’t have real proof, just a hunch.

Galaxy’s Child – a very short bit (50 seconds) of reaction shots of the bridge crew being fascinated with the space baby and Picard and Worf reciting a nursery rhyme. Pretty awkward stuff.

Qpid – Q as The Sheriff of Nottingham talks a bit more to Sir Guy of Gisbourne about how to make life miserable for Robin Hood.

The Host – Odan, now in Riker, is having issues sharing consciousness with Riker, in the cut scene he finds himself compelled to play poker with Riker’s friends since he seems to have a combination of both Odan and Riker emerging.

More Season 4 Images

family_01_small

brothers_02_small

devilsdue_01_small

fc_01_small

gc_02_small

identity_01_small

me_01_small

me_02_small

nth_01_small

nth_02_small

qpid_01_small

qpid_02_small

wounded_01_small

wounded_02_small

wounded_03_small

Comments

1. Cardy Corner Mouth Mustache - August 1, 2013

I’m ready for my close-up.

2. Cardy Corner Mouth Mustache - August 1, 2013

Sigh…. I’ve had trouble getting work since….

3. TNG lover - August 1, 2013

Everytime i read about TNG i wish they had one more season…i still wish and they can still have …atleast a short burst of few episodes…

4. Bird of Prey - August 1, 2013

Wonderful screenshots! Especially 24th century rural France and the close-up of the ur-Cardassian’s make-up!!

5. Ensign RedShirt - August 1, 2013

Great review, Matt. Starting watching the set last night. All of the outdoor photography from “Family” looks gorgeous. Rob Burnett and Roger Lay are really doing amazing work on those docs.

6. Kev - August 1, 2013

did they accidentally leave a piece on the model here before filming? as the left engine here looks very rough

http://scifanatic.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/nth_03.jpg

and screws up an otherwise beautiful shot.

7. DJT - August 1, 2013

Got it.

Extras are a little on the thin side (deleted scenes much appreciated). However, there are a TONS of excellent episodes here. Still a great buy.

P.S. while i love everyone in the Art Dept, the way the doc was shot [heresy, i know] was kind of off.

8. Leah - August 1, 2013

Kev, can you be more specific? Do you mean picture left or ship left?

I only see the Enterprise and the arms of the station.

9. Matt Wright - August 1, 2013

@ 6 — That’s the 4-footer, I assume you mean the small detail towards the back of nacelle? FYI: It’s in the original camera footage. Here it is in SD as well:
http://tng.trekcore.com/gallery/albums/s4/4×19/thenthdegree257.jpg

That little detail is raised on the 4-footer, where it was flush in the 6-foot version. The lighting of that scene makes the shadows fall on the left nacelle and make it clearly outlined.
You can see that detail in The Defector too (the first episode to use the 4-footer).
http://tng.trekcore.com/hd/albums/3×10/the_defector_hd_085.jpg

10. Skippy2k - August 1, 2013

You mean where the “panel” with the two indention on the nacelle which are usually flush? Maybe an access panel to the workings or attachment not fully closed?

11. Skippy2k - August 1, 2013

Ah, that explains it…never really cared for the 4 footer. Nice bit of info, thanks!

12. DS9 IN PRIME TIEM - August 2, 2013

This is awsome!

13. Nx01 - August 2, 2013

Is there nothing they can do about aspect ratio. I hate watching this aspect ratio on my wide screen Tv with the sides cut off. The digital blue rips seem to fix that problem.

I purchased best of both worlds, and the quality is not much better than the original DVD release.

14. MattR - August 2, 2013

#13 There’s nothing cut off. What do you want them to do? Crop it to 16×9, or have boom mics and lighting/camera equipment in the scene?

15. SFC3 - August 2, 2013

#13

You must be blind. Saying the DVD of BOBW is way better than the BluRay is truly idiotic.

16. Martin J. Pollard - August 2, 2013

#13 – I’ve seen the episodes on BBC America that were cropped on the top and bottom to better fit widescreen TVs. They look terrible, and a good chunk of the picture is lost. I’d rather have the black bars on the sides while preserving the 4:3 aspect ratio than compromise the picture in order to accommodate 16:9 screens.

17. Ron - August 2, 2013

CAN ANYONE HELP?? i have been trying to contact someone at trekmovie. I attended the unveiling of the Galileo from TOS at Space Center Houston and have awesome pictures of the event and a story and no one has responded to me. Can we submit stories here?

18. Mike C. - August 3, 2013

#13: Your TV or Blu-ray should have a zoom option. Learn how to use it.

19. rogerachong - August 3, 2013

OMG they are reporting that Kang died on Wednesday!

20. Danpaine - August 3, 2013

Yup, confirmed. Michael Ansara died, he was 91. Great character actor. RIP, Kang……

21. Trekbilly - August 3, 2013

RIP, MIchael Ansara! One of the greatest actors to portray a Klingon ever! He also made an excellent Kane on Buck Rogers…one of the very few bright spots on that show!

22. Caesar - August 3, 2013

The Wounded really was great. I can take or leave Family though, and Brothers downright stinks.

23. ironhyde - August 3, 2013

In family, it always bothered me how the green in the foreground and the matt painting were different colours.. more blue in the painting. Disappointed they didn’t fix that this time around, but hey… TNG looks beautiful, so I’m all smiles :)

24. King Kang - August 3, 2013

RIP Michael Ansara

http://www.thespec.com/whatson-story/3923855-star-trek-s-original-klingon-michael-ansara-dies/

25. Sebi - August 4, 2013

RIP, Michael Ansara! The great actor gave us one of the most memorable Klingons ever!

26. jas_montreal - August 4, 2013

RIP Michael Ansara.

Whats happened to trekmovie.com lately? Barely any posts. Not up to date with the latest news.

27. Ayse Gül - August 4, 2013

Lately? It’s like that for months now.

28. (The Late) Richard Dawson's Ruffled Shirt - August 4, 2013

26
There’s “latest” movie news right now? What?

29. Danpaine - August 5, 2013

TrekToday or TrekNews are the places to go for anything current. I just stop by here to see what you people are fighting about from time to time.

30. Jim - August 5, 2013

#13 For the millionth time YES there is nothing they can do unless you want boom mic and cameras in all your shots, or to loose anything at the top and bottom of the screen.

Its been stated multiple times the show was filmed in 3/4 so it HAS to be shown at that ratio because even though 35mm is wide enough for more shot to be seen, they blocked off their cameras so that they were purposely shooting a 3/4 frame, so if you opened it up full frame you would see the sets.

Seriously just deal with it, stop whining.

31. Chain of Command - August 5, 2013

Season 4 was also the year Ron Jones was unceremoniously canned, Thus beginning the long run of anti-climactic, uninspiring and unmemorable sonic wallpaper. LOL

32. (The Late) Richard Dawson's Ruffled Shirt - August 5, 2013

holy crap, AGAIN with the 4×3 vs 16×9 bitching?

33. Danpaine - August 5, 2013

Folks may find this interesting….I did:

http://news.moviefone.com/2013/08/05/neill-blomkamp-star-trek/

No Trek for him.

34. Disinvited - August 5, 2013

#13. Nx01 – August 2, 2013

Besides. it’s silly to go into art and photo museums and tell their directors that their works of art are wrong because their framers decided to mount them with borders – white or otherwise.

You can complain that you like your circles to fill your rectangular frame without borders all you want. Fact is, if you so change the artist’s circle into a rectangle you are defacing a work of art largely to service an obsessive compulsive disorder which ultimately has no rational artistic merit behind it.

35. Adama - August 5, 2013

It looks like as if Paramount wants to kill the franchise:

http://latino-review.com/2013/08/05/exclusive-we-know-who-the-top-contender-is-to-direct-star-trek-3/

O_O

36. Calastir - August 6, 2013

#35.
True, even worse is that they don’t just kill the franchise, but sadistically keep on molesting it.

So sad, you can hardly parody this crap…

37. Evan - August 6, 2013

Not to pick nits, but it’s Barclay, not Barkley.

38. Chain of Command - August 6, 2013

I always thought that TNG’s fourth season was its’ best. The third and sixth seasons were great, but the fourth is when it really felt like the show produced a lot of great episodes.

The cast also seemed to have more fun during this year. It just seemed, overall, to be the most mature of TNG’s seven seasons.

39. Basement Blogger - August 7, 2013

A couple of my favorites from season four are The Nth Degree and Future Imperfect. Both episodes were smart and emotional. And they very much kept to Roddenberry’s vision. Those shows lacked the action that the movies are mandated to have and demonstrate that Star Trek belongs on television.

40. The Original Spock's Brain - August 9, 2013

@ 17 Ron
I live in Houston and have a blog (couldn’t attend the unveiling). Would love to publsh your pictures. Please contact me. http://mobettablog.com/mobettablog/Blog/Entries/2013/6/30_Entry_1.html

41. ripped - August 11, 2013

rips are already on usenet for those who cant afford to pay for it or do not want to period (aka me)

42. Factchecker - August 12, 2013

DISC 2 ERROR: Anybody else have a problem with playback freezing about 25 min. into “FUTURE IMPERFECT?”

Does anybody have an email address for CBS/Paramount customer support?

43. LiamKav - August 12, 2013

#41

You mean for morons who don’t think that people deserve to be paid for the work they’ve put into this and so are happy to steal it? I’m glad the show managed to teach you so much about morals.

44. Justin Olson - August 12, 2013

@ 42 Factchecker:

No problem with that disc or episode here. Have you tried exchanging the set at the retailer you got it from first? It’s been less than two weeks since the set came out, so you still should be able to do that. If for some reason that’s not an option, try using the contact information at this link:

http://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=9223

45. Garak's Pride - August 13, 2013

Lamest looking drydock ever. And the wine fields in 24th Century France look unconvincing. And the lame holodeck stuff looks like something out of 1980′s Murder She Wrote. TNG is not aging well at all, and the HD just makes it worse. A bit of fuzziness actually helped the cheap production values and special effects to be OK before; but now HD shows the problems and issues for us all to see.

46. Garak's Pride - August 13, 2013

#41. Congrats, you f’ng crook. I hope the NSA — who probably reads all web sites like they do phone calls — passes your ID info to the FBI and that you get prosecuted for illegal copying of this.

47. Disinvited - August 13, 2013

#43. LiamKav – August 12, 2013

Having coded for a living, I understand the train of thought the leads to outbursts such as yours. But my years of exposure in college to philosophy makes me realize that this notion that people should suppress their inherent apish nature that leads them to freely copy and imitate, is a relative recent invention in the mind of man. I don’t mind it being pointed out that ripping violates laws and has consequences, but this MPAA con job that it violates man’s inherent sense of the wrongness of depriving another of their physical property is hogwash.

Also, that eidetic memory exists is a fact. Until the hormonal ravages of puberty changed it personally for me, I had it. I refuse to accept on the behalf of eidetic people the world over this new MPAA notion that because they can replay movies in their mind, on demand, and have no need for discs or other “approved” replay services, that they must now therefore be branded thieves because they have no need for discs or other replay services.

Current copyright and patent law is just one of many ways that creative peoples have been rewarded and stimulated to continue to do so throughout human history. There is nothing ideal about it – it is just a way to do it. It needs to evolve or at least have some game plan to address the very real possibility that medical science at the very least or some other disruptive technology is going to bankrupt the industry’s current approach of desperately trying to prop up an antiquated system.

48. MJ (The Original). - August 13, 2013

Disinvited,

We are going to have to part ways on this one. I agree with LiamKav and Garak’s pride. I have no sympathy pirates, period. Most of these types of people are already living off of their parents; many do drugs and smoke week, and many can’t hold down a job. So they want stuff for free because they are to lazy, and don’t have the morals, to do the right thing.

49. Justin Olson - August 13, 2013

@ 45. Garak’s Pride:

On the contrary, TNG did not have cheap production values! By 1992, each episode had a $2 million budget — nearly double that of a normal network drama at the time — or $3.3 million today, adjusted for inflation. Multiply that by 26 episodes, and the cost becomes nearly $86 million for a single season.

http://articles.latimes.com/print/1992-11-06/entertainment/ca-1286_1_television-star-trek

That’s about as much as LOST by the way. LOST had a budget of around $3.2 million per episode but also benefited greatly from the Hawaii Production Tax Credit. Seasons 3-6 cost $228 million according to this link:

http://www.businessinsider.com/lost-spent-228-million-filming-in-hawaii-2010-4

50. Disinvited - August 13, 2013

#48. MJ (The Original). – August 13, 2013

I can accept the much better lobbied MPAA position makes me a minority but I still say the movie industry is going to bankrupt itself when medical science improves every human memory to the point where their current position is untenable and most unfortunate that they won’t be ready to adapt. Just want people to be aware that copying what others do is older than the current solution as it predates the invention of money/economics, and even began with our ancestors copying other sentient species:

http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/story/2013/08/12/technology-modern-human-neandertal-lissoir.html

51. devonp - August 28, 2013

My discs 1-5 are great with no issues! However disc 6 with “In Theory” has freezing issues at around 42-43 minutes into play when Jenna goes to Data’s quarters to break up with him. I haven’t watched Redemption part I yet but I am not concerned as I have purchased the “Redemption” Blu Ray Disc separately as well just as I did for “The Best of Both Worlds”. However, little snags or imperfections like this drive me nuts, especially when you pay a good penny $$$ for these products! I have supported Paramount by buying all Star Trek Products many times over in all their incarnations: VHS, DVD, Remastered & now Blu Ray. How can I contact them for a Replacement disc or is this even possible? Thanks

52. Matt Wright - September 2, 2013

Sorry I didn’t see your comment about a defective disc sooner.
I don’t have any direct contact info for CBS Home Entertainment, I would try asking on their Twitter or Facebook
http://www.cbshomeentertainment.com/

TrekMovie.com is represented by Gorilla Nation. Please contact Gorilla Nation for ad rates, packages and general advertising information.